Collateral damage mechanics

I suggest collateral damage is only applied if the defending units get defeated.
Otherwise the defending player suffers from it even if he did everything correctly.
This doesnt feel right for me. It also messes with the balance. Strats that rely on
units without collateral damage or focus on defending are noticeably weaker now.

People die in Gaza and Ashkelon but the cities are not captured

The point is like a siege. Render the city useless then take it.

Napisao Utah, 24.11.2012 at 22:28

The point is like a siege. Render the city useless then take it.

Render the city useless? I have had a city reduced to 1% of population (minimum) and yet it had 120%+ of income...